The Quiet Burden of Stewardship
The unseen hardships of raising animals
There is a side to raising animals that rarely makes it into photographs, conversations, or the romanticized idea of ranch life. It isn't the beautiful sunrises, the newborn animals finding their feet, or the peaceful sight of livestock grazing across open range.
It is the weight of being responsible for lives other than your own, and as a mother, lives outside my children.
It is knowing that, on any given day, you may be called upon to make a decision that determines whether another living creature gets to see tomorrow.
And sometimes, no matter how much you care, how hard you try, or how desperately you wish for a different outcome, there simply isn't one.
When you raise animals, you become many things. You are a caretaker, a protector, a provider, and a steward. You learn to recognize the smallest changes in behavior. The way they walk, the way they eat, the way they hold their heads. You notice when someone is missing from the herd, when an animal doesn't come running for feed, or when something simply doesn't feel right. You become trained to look for wounds, legs wrapped in some foreign trash, swelling from a snakebite or worse.
You become, out of necessity, a vet of sorts. Not because you believe yourself more qualified than someone who has dedicated their life to veterinary medicine, but because sometimes there is no one else. Our vet was in his late 70’s when he was called to a higher purpose - Rest in Peace, Doc Lytle. We have since tried 2 others. We rely on each for their areas of expertise, though the lifestyle and learnings of decades on ranches will be missed.
A large animal vet in Arizona may cover vast areas, so a quick call to the vet can result in a couple day delay of being seen. Out here, help isn't always a phone call away. There are distances to consider, hours in the day, financial realities, and the simple fact that large-animal veterinarians are becoming increasingly difficult to find.
Emergencies don't wait for convenient hours, and suffering doesn't stop while you search for someone willing or able to come.
So you learn.
You learn to administer medications, dress wounds, recognize illness, assist with births, and make animals comfortable. Some of us are more experienced or more willing to do certain things others may not. Which is another thing that makes us so grateful for the team we have in our family. Over the years you learn; how to place an IV in large animals, castration, minor surgery, tubing etc.
You learn through books, conversations, experience, and sometimes through mistakes you wish you could take back.
I have twin lambs from last Winter, (winter lambs if you will) who were born from one of my favorite Ewes, we called her Deer. Deer was standoffish, stompy and wild. She fit her name. She was lightly mottled and light brown. Raised healthy lambs each year. She was bit by a rattler a few years ago, I believe, by trying to stomp the snake that bit her lamb. Both showed up swollen and grumpy one day. They survived just fine - sheep blood is actually the most common way of creating anti-venom for the diamondback rattle snake! (Look up CROFAB)
Anyway, I liked her a lot. This last Winter she birthed triplets, she developed pregnancy toxemia or ‘twin lamb disease’. I lost her fairly quickly, even after days and days of hand feeding a sheep drench for more nutrients and minerals. I lost the triplet boy through the night, he passed wrapped up in my heating pad in my home. Carla and Darla made it through, they became my bottle babies and still follow us around. I can’t send those two to harvest now…which means we lost a yielding ewe and 3 lambs for the meat process. Not great for business, even worse for my mental state that month.

Perhaps the hardest lesson of all is learning that doing everything within your power doesn't always mean you've done enough.
There is a particular kind of helplessness in that realization.
In this day and age, we don’t all raise our own food - so it is become less common for the average person to experience this.
That isn't a criticism. In many ways, it is a wonderful thing. Most people can take a sick pet to a veterinarian, rely on professionals to make difficult medical decisions, or simply live their lives without ever having to weigh suffering against the possibility of recovery.
But for those of us who raise animals, these decisions are sometimes an unavoidable part of an otherwise ordinary Tuesday.
One moment, you're making breakfast, tending to children, or planning the day's work. The next, you're standing over an animal you've cared for since birth, trying to determine whether another treatment might help or whether continuing to try is only prolonging its suffering.
You consider everything. The animal's condition, the likelihood of recovery, the resources available, the time already spent trying, and what its quality of life might look like if it survives.
And somewhere among all those practical considerations is a human being who desperately wants the animal to live.
That is the part I think people often overlook.
We aren't immune to the suffering around us simply because we encounter it more frequently.
Last night after taking a break from doctoring a prolapse on a pig, I found one of roosters barely moving, crumpled up in the garden. Breathing sounds like a respiratory problem, not an animal attack. I sit there looking into his eyes… seeing his willingness to try and move, but also seeing his eye roll back, his legs give out, he breathing getting harder and harder. I could put him in a separate area and doctor him, as I’ve done time and time again for other hens after winter rain.
They all died the same, slowly I’m sure, by the time I came back to continue the effort. I couldn't let that happen to him this time…
Experience may teach us how to respond more calmly. It may give us the knowledge to recognize when an outcome is unlikely to change. It may even teach us to accept death as an inevitable part of life.
But it doesn't necessarily make the decisions hurt any less.
Sometimes, I think it makes them harder.
Because with experience comes the memory of every animal you couldn't save. Every decision you questioned afterward. Every time you wondered whether you should have acted sooner, waited longer, tried something different, or recognized a symptom before it became something more serious.
There is guilt in losing an animal despite your best efforts.
There is guilt in choosing to end a life to prevent further suffering.
And, strangely enough, there can even be guilt in knowing that ending that suffering was the kindest thing you could have done.
You can know something was necessary and still wish with everything in you that it hadn't been.
I don't think those feelings ever completely leave you.
They accumulate quietly alongside the years of experience, the successful births, the animals that recovered against the odds, and the countless ordinary days when everything went exactly as it should.
We carry those losses while continuing to care for the lives still depending on us.
Because the work doesn't stop when your heart hurts.
The other animals still need water. The fences still need checking. The feed still needs to be delivered. There are children to raise, meals to make, orders to confirm and responsibilities that don't disappear simply because you've had a difficult morning.
Sometimes, you wipe your eyes, wash your hands, and move on to the next chore.
Not because what happened didn't matter.
But because everything else still does.
And perhaps that is one of the loneliest parts of this life. There often isn't much room to process what has happened before the day demands something else of you.
My sons and I have a graveyard of the animals we have lost. Not ‘ours’ but we were witness to their loss. Sparrow chicks who’ve fallen from their nest, rabbits and owls hit on the road, a hawk we tried saving from drowning, my first ‘house’ chicken who’s head was stolen by a raccoon and the triplet who didn’t survive the night.
I refuse to become calloused to loss.
There is a difficult contradiction in raising animals for food while caring so deeply about their lives.
We know that some of the animals in our care will eventually be harvested. We have accepted that responsibility as part of providing food for our families and our community. But accepting that reality doesn't mean we view their lives as disposable, or that an unexpected loss somehow matters less.
Quite the opposite.
I believe that raising animals with the knowledge that their lives will eventually end places an even greater responsibility on us to make the time they have worthwhile.
To give them space, comfort, proper care, and the opportunity to live as naturally as we can provide. To move them gently, recognize their individual needs, and minimize fear and unnecessary suffering.
To remember that they are living creatures, not simply numbers on a spreadsheet or products waiting to be sold.
There is an enormous difference between accepting death as part of life and becoming indifferent to it.
I hope I never become indifferent.
I hope I always feel something when an animal dies, even when the loss is expected. I hope I never find it easy to make the decision to end suffering, even when I know it is the right decision.
Because I believe that discomfort is part of what keeps us accountable.
It reminds us that the responsibility we carry is not something to take lightly.
So, we have a butcher who also carries the same respect for life. We don't haul meat animals hours away to be dealt with by folks they don't know.
Of course, there are those who may look at the decisions we make and believe they would have chosen differently. Perhaps they would have. From a distance, with unlimited time, resources, and possibilities, many decisions can appear much simpler than they are.
But the reality of caring for living creatures is rarely so clear.
Sometimes there is no perfect answer. Sometimes every option carries a degree of suffering, uncertainty, or loss. Sometimes the best decision available is still a terrible one to have to make.
And sometimes, despite all the knowledge you've gained, you simply have to trust your judgment and live with the outcome.
I think about how much of modern life allows us to remain separated from these realities. We are often removed from the origins of our food, the fragility of life, and the difficult choices involved in caring for animals. We can appreciate the beauty of the natural world without always having to witness its harsher truths. Coyotes still eat rabbits, vulture still scavenge the dead, mountain lions still hunt young wildlife and on the flipside; old lions still slowly starve, bears go hungry, coyotes get mange and get sicker and sicker...
But those truths exist whether we see them or not.
Life is fragile. Nature is not gentle. And loving something does not grant us the ability to save it.
Here on the ranch, we are reminded of that more often than I would like. Which is likely the reason none of us are hunters as well - though we support those who do so for their families or conservation.
Yet, even with the heartbreak, I wouldn't want to lose the compassion that makes this work difficult.
Because alongside the loss, there is so much life.
There are newborn animals taking their first uncertain steps. There are recoveries we once thought impossible. There are animals who recognize our voices, follow us through their pastures, and trust us to bring them what they need.
There are small moments of connection that most people will never witness, and a sense of responsibility that reaches far beyond the animals themselves, into the land, the wildlife, and the generations who will come after us.
All of it matters.
The joy and the grief. The responsibility and the privilege. The lives saved and the lives lost.
I don't share these thoughts looking for sympathy, nor do I believe that our hardships are greater than those faced by people living different lives.
I share them because I think there is value in understanding the weight of work that is so often seen only from the outside.
Raising animals isn't simply about keeping them fed until they are grown. It is about showing up for them every day, including the days when doing so asks more of you emotionally than you feel capable of giving.
It is about accepting responsibility for creatures who cannot explain where they hurt, what they need, or when they have had enough.
It is about making decisions you never wanted to make, carrying the consequences of those decisions, and still choosing to care just as deeply for the next life placed in your hands.
We cannot promise every animal a long life. We cannot promise that every illness will be cured, every injury healed, or every effort rewarded.
But we can promise that their lives will matter to us.
That we will continue learning, continue trying, and continue questioning ourselves when things go wrong.
That we will never confuse necessity with indifference.
And that even when the responsibility feels unbearably heavy, we will do our best to carry it with compassion.
Because being a good steward of life doesn't mean you will always be able to save it.
Sometimes, it means having the courage to care for it through the very end.
And then finding the strength to do it all again tomorrow.
Somewhere on the ranch,
Savannah Barteau











Comments